Clause guide
Primary and Noncontributory: What the Clause Means in Your MSA
What “primary and noncontributory” asks of your insurance, the endorsements that deliver it (CG 20 01, CA 04 49), what it costs your limits and how to redline it.
Redline Coverage Editors · Updated November 16, 2026
What the two words do
Every liability policy has an “Other Insurance” condition that decides who pays when more than one policy covers the same loss. Left alone, two policies that both apply on a primary basis share the loss, by equal shares or in proportion to their limits. That is the outcome an enterprise customer is trying to avoid when its insurance exhibit says your coverage must be primary and noncontributory:
- Primary: your policy responds first for the customer, before the customer’s own insurance is touched.
- Noncontributory: your insurer will not turn around and demand that the customer’s insurer contribute to the defense or the settlement.
Together they keep a loss that comes from your product or your work off the customer’s own claims history and limits. The clause rides on additional insured status: it governs how your policy treats the customer as an insured, so a customer who is not an additional insured on your policy gets nothing from it.
Where it comes from on your policy
Primary and noncontributory status is not built into a standard policy. It is added by an endorsement, and each line of coverage the MSA names needs its own.
| Coverage the MSA names | What delivers primary and noncontributory | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial general liability | ISO CG 20 01, “Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance Condition”, or a carrier’s own blanket wording | That it is on your forms schedule, and that it also reaches products-completed operations |
| Commercial auto | ISO CA 04 49, or a carrier’s own wording | Whether the MSA requires auto at all for a deployment that doesn’t put your vehicles on site |
| Umbrella or excess | No default: an umbrella is excess by design. ISO’s 2023 umbrella filing added CU 24 77; many carriers use their own wording | Whether your carrier will endorse it at all, and the order of response the MSA asks for |
| Workers’ compensation | Not how this line works: customers ask for a waiver of subrogation instead | Strike primary and noncontributory language aimed at workers’ comp |
| Cyber, tech E&O | Rarely available, since these policies seldom add additional insureds | Push back before signing, rather than promise what the carrier won’t endorse |
The ISO general liability form is narrower than the contract language it answers. CG 20 01 makes your insurance primary and noncontributory for an additional insured only when two conditions are met: the additional insured is a Named Insured on the other insurance, and you agreed in writing, in a contract or agreement, that your insurance would be primary and would not seek contribution. A handshake promise, or a customer’s parent company that isn’t the Named Insured on the customer’s policy, can fall outside it. Carrier-specific forms differ, so read the form your policy actually carries; your forms schedule lists every endorsement by number and edition date.
What it costs you
The real cost is in your limits, not only in any premium. When your policy is primary for a customer, the customer’s defense and settlement come out of the same per-occurrence and aggregate limits that protect you. A startup carrying thin limits against a customer with a large risk program is lending that customer its tower, which is why the limits an enterprise demands and this clause have to be read together.
Whether the endorsement adds premium depends on the carrier: some include it in a blanket additional insured package, others charge for it or add it only on request. Ask your broker for the premium effect, in writing, before you agree to it in the MSA.
Why robotics and hardware vendors should read it twice
For a company shipping autonomous systems, two gaps sit underneath the clause:
- Completed operations. A robot keeps operating long after installation. If your additional insured endorsement covers only ongoing operations, primary and noncontributory status has nothing to attach to once the deployment is finished. Check that the additional insured wording reaches completed operations, and that the primary and noncontributory endorsement does too.
- AI exclusions. Being primary for the customer means nothing for a loss the policy excludes. If your general liability policy carries an exclusion for losses involving AI or autonomous decision-making, the customer may be asking for affirmative AI coverage as well.
How to review the clause before you sign
- List every line it applies to. “All policies required herein shall be primary and noncontributory” sweeps in workers’ comp, cyber and E&O. Narrow it to general liability, auto and, where your carrier will endorse it, umbrella.
- Tie it to your share of the risk. Ask that your insurance be primary only for claims arising out of your products, operations or negligence, so the customer’s own negligence stays with the customer’s insurer. Your counsel can draft the exact wording.
- Match the contract to the form. Send the MSA’s insurance exhibit to your broker before signing and ask whether your current endorsements satisfy it as written, line by line.
- Hedge the umbrella. Where the MSA requires the umbrella to be noncontributory, ask for “to the extent available on commercially reasonable terms” unless your broker confirms the carrier will endorse it.
- Make it blanket. A blanket endorsement that applies “where required by written contract” saves a policy change for every new customer. Ask your broker whether your carrier offers one.
- Check the order of signing. Some endorsements apply only to contracts signed before the loss. Have the insurance terms agreed in writing before the robots arrive on site.
Each of these is easier to win early. The negotiating guide for pre-revenue hardware startups covers how to raise them without stalling the deal.
Proving it to the customer
A certificate of insurance (the ACORD 25 most customers ask for) states that it is issued as a matter of information only and confers no rights on the certificate holder. Typing “primary and noncontributory” into its description box does not change your policy. That is why a careful customer asks for a copy of the endorsement itself. Have your broker send the certificate together with the endorsement pages that grant additional insured status, primary and noncontributory status and any waiver of subrogation, and keep the set on file for renewal, when the edition dates may change.
Common questions
- Is primary and noncontributory the same as additional insured?
- No. Additional insured status makes the customer an insured under your policy. Primary and noncontributory decides the order in which policies pay for that customer: yours first, without asking the customer's insurer to share. The second only has effect once the first is in place.
- Can I refuse a primary and noncontributory requirement?
- Enterprise customers rarely drop it for general liability, so refusing outright tends to stall the deal. What is usually negotiable is its scope: which lines it covers, and whether it applies only to claims arising out of your products or operations.
- Does a certificate of insurance prove primary and noncontributory status?
- No. A certificate is informational and confers no rights. The proof is the endorsement on your policy, so send its pages with the certificate.
- Does my umbrella follow my general liability policy's primary and noncontributory endorsement?
- Not reliably. An umbrella is excess by design, and follow-form wording may not carry an endorsement from the underlying policy. If the MSA requires it, ask your broker whether your umbrella carrier will add its own noncontributory wording.
This guide explains common contract and policy language. It is not legal advice, and endorsement wording varies by carrier and edition: check your own policy’s forms schedule with your broker, and the contract with your counsel.
Sources
- CG 20 01 12 19, Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance Condition (ISO) · The general liability endorsement’s full text, including its two conditions.
- CA 04 49 11 16, Primary and Noncontributory – Other Insurance Condition (ISO) · The commercial auto counterpart.
- When is an Umbrella Primary and Noncontributory? (IA Magazine) · Why follow-form umbrella wording may not carry the underlying endorsement.
- Noncontributory and Order of Response – Other Insurance Condition, CU 24 77 · ISO’s umbrella endorsement from its 2023 filing.
- Primary and Noncontributory Provisions and Priority of Coverage (American Bar Association) · How courts have read these provisions when policies collide.


